Why Are Long Islanders Relocating to Northeast Florida?

Why Long Islanders Are Moving to Northeast Florida

Long Island has long been a dream destination for many New Yorkers — close to the city, surrounded by beaches, and filled with established communities. But in recent years, more and more Long Islanders are looking south, with Northeast Florida — particularly St. Augustine FL and Palm Coast — becoming a top relocation spot.

High housing costs, heavy taxes, and chilly winters in New York are motivating families, retirees, and even young professionals to explore a better quality of life in Florida. For those considering moving to St. Augustine Florida or Palm Coast, the appeal is stronger than ever.

So, why are Long Islanders choosing Northeast Florida? Let’s dive into the major reasons.

Cost of Living & Housing

  • Housing Prices:

    • Long Island: Median home prices often exceed $600,000–$700,000, with waterfront homes reaching into the millions.

    • St. Augustine & Palm Coast: Median home prices are closer to $350,000–$450,000, making coastal living far more attainable.

  • Taxes:

    • Long Island: Among the highest property taxes in the nation plus New York’s state income tax.

    • Florida: No state income tax and lower property taxes, leading to substantial savings.

  • Utilities & Expenses: While Florida summers require higher air conditioning costs, the absence of winter heating and snow removal more than balances it out.

👉 This makes St. Augustine real estate and Palm Coast properties more budget-friendly than comparable Long Island homes.

Weather & Lifestyle

  • Climate: Long Islanders endure long, snowy winters. Northeast Florida offers year-round sunshine with mild winters and warm summers.

  • Outdoor Activities:

    • Long Island: Summer beach trips, seasonal boating, and limited warm-weather months.

    • St. Augustine & Palm Coast: Beaches, golf, boating, fishing, and outdoor dining are a year-round lifestyle.

  • Pace of Life: Florida’s coastal towns offer a relaxed, laid-back vibe compared to the fast pace of Long Island suburbs.

For many, this slower coastal rhythm is one of the top places to live in St. Augustine Florida compared to busy metro suburbs.

Jobs, Retirement & Community

  • Jobs: While Long Island benefits from proximity to NYC, remote work has freed many families to live where they want — making moving to St. Augustine FL or Palm Coast more appealing. Healthcare, hospitality, and construction are strong local industries.

  • Retirement: Many Long Islanders head south for retirement. Florida’s tax benefits, active 55+ communities, and sunny weather make it ideal.

  • Family-Friendly Communities: St. Johns County Florida and Flagler County have seen a boom in master-planned communities with amenities like pools, parks, and golf courses — perfect for young families.

Local Insights

What makes Northeast Florida stand out?

  • St. Augustine: The nation’s oldest city, filled with history, cobblestone streets, festivals, and family-friendly neighborhoods.

  • Palm Coast: Known for affordability, beautiful canals, and easy access to both beaches and nature preserves.

  • Lifestyle Perks: From world-class golf courses to boating on the Intracoastal Waterway, the area offers something Long Islanders often pay a premium for — at a fraction of the cost.

Practical Considerations

  • Distance: Moving from Long Island to Northeast Florida means a drive of 1,000+ miles, often requiring movers or vehicle shipping.

  • Real Estate Market: The St. Augustine and Palm Coast markets are competitive but still affordable compared to Long Island.

  • Tips: Visit first, explore communities like Nocatee, Palm Harbor, and Villano Beach, and connect with a local agent before making the leap.

Conclusion

For Long Islanders, the draw to Northeast Florida is clear: lower housing costs, tax savings, better weather, and a relaxed lifestyle. Whether for retirement or raising a family, St. Augustine and Palm Coast offer the perfect blend of affordability and coastal charm.

👉 Thinking of trading Long Island winters for Florida sunshine? Our team specializes in helping New Yorkers relocate to St. Augustine and Palm Coast — Contact the Kim Devlin Team and let’s find your perfect home today.