Calling everyone who put moving to Florida on their 2025 Vision Board!
Choosing the perfect place to call home is a big decision, especially when considering two amazing Florida cities like Jacksonville and St. Augustine. Both offer unique qualities that appeal to different lifestyles and budgets. In this guide, we’ll break down the real estate markets, cost of living, and lifestyle perks of each city to help you decide which one is right for you.
Real Estate Market
Jacksonville: As one of Florida’s largest cities, Jacksonville boasts a diverse real estate market. From luxury waterfront properties to affordable suburban homes, there’s something for everyone. According to Redfin, the November 2024 median home price in Jacksonville was approximately $303,000, making it an attractive option for families and professionals alike.
St. Augustine: Known for its historic charm and coastal vibes, St. Augustine offers a more boutique real estate market. The median home price is slightly higher at around $475,000, reflecting the city’s unique architecture and proximity to the beach. St. Augustine is ideal for those seeking a smaller, tight-knit community with plenty of character.
Key Takeaway: Jacksonville provides a wider range of housing options and price points, while St. Augustine leans toward charming, upscale properties with a coastal feel.
Cost of Living
Jacksonville: As a larger metro area, Jacksonville offers a relatively low cost of living – 11% less than the national average – compared to other major U.S. cities. Utilities, groceries, and transportation are all moderately priced, making it a budget-friendly choice for families and young professionals.
St. Augustine: While St. Augustine’s cost of living is slightly higher than Jacksonville’s, it’s still affordable by Florida standards still coming in at 2% lower than the national average! The premium comes from its boutique shopping, historical attractions, and proximity to the beach, which adds to the overall value of living here.
Key Takeaway: Jacksonville is the more budget-friendly option, while St. Augustine offers a slightly higher cost of living with unique perks.
Lifestyle and Community
Jacksonville If you love urban living with access to beaches, parks, and a vibrant job market, Jacksonville is your city. With professional sports teams, a thriving arts scene, and diverse dining options, there’s never a dull moment. Its larger population means more networking opportunities and cultural diversity.
St. Augustine St. Augustine’s charm lies in its historic downtown, stunning beaches, and small-town atmosphere. Known as the nation’s oldest city, it offers a slower pace of life with a focus on local culture and outdoor activities. It’s perfect for retirees, families, or anyone looking for a serene coastal lifestyle.
Key Takeaway: Jacksonville offers a bustling, urban lifestyle, while St. Augustine is ideal for those seeking a quieter, historic, and beach-centric community.
Schools and Education
Jacksonville Jacksonville is home to numerous public and private schools and higher education institutions like the University of North Florida and Jacksonville University. Families will appreciate the variety of educational options.
St. Augustine St. Augustine has a smaller selection of schools but excels in community-focused education. St. Johns County consistently ranks as one of the best school districts in Florida, making it a great choice for families with school-aged children.
Key Takeaway: Both cities offer quality education, but St. Augustine’s school district stands out for families.
Things to Do
- Enjoy the Jacksonville Zoo and Gardens.
- Explore downtown nightlife and entertainment.
- Relax on 22 miles of beaches.
- Stroll through the historic district.
- Visit iconic landmarks like Castillo de San Marcos.
- Unwind at Anastasia State Park.
Key Takeaway: Jacksonville offers big-city attractions, while St. Augustine delivers historical charm and coastal beauty.
Conclusion Both Jacksonville and St. Augustine have their own unique appeal. Jacksonville is perfect for those who want an urban lifestyle with diverse opportunities, while St. Augustine is ideal for those seeking charm, history, and a slower pace of life. Your decision will depend on your priorities—whether it’s affordability, lifestyle, or community. No matter which city you choose, you’ll find a welcoming home in the Sunshine State.
CONTACT US to learn more about life in St. Augustine!