St. Augustine, FL’s Ultimate Gift Guide: Perfect Presents for Every Personality
This holiday season (or any season), treat your loved ones to something truly special with treasures from St. Augustine’s most unique local shops. From whimsical toys to gourmet desserts, our charming city has something for everyone. Whether you’re shopping for the adventurer, the sweet tooth, or the chic decorator, these stores are a goldmine for thoughtful gifting.
Here’s your guide to the best gifts St. Augustine has to offer – so good, even Oprah would be proud:
🎁 For the Playful Spirit: Toytopia
Visit one of their 3 locations around town and enter their magical world where childhood nostalgia meets modern fun. This enchanting store has games, puzzles, plush toys, and collectibles that delight all ages. They’ve even got special Jellycats at their STA locations!
- Address: 355 Pine Lake Dr. Ste D103, Nocatee, FL 32081 | 70 Silver Forest Dr. Suite 111 St. Augustine, FL 32092 | 300 S Ponce De Leon Blvd, St. Augustine, FL 32084
- Perfect Gift: A classic board game or an intricate puzzle for family game night.
- Who Will Love It: Kids, the young at heart, and nostalgic gift-givers.
🎁 For the Coffee Lover: Juniper Market
A market haven for good coffee, homemade pastries, and curated treasures that celebrate coastal living. A true local hotspot!
- Address: 48 San Marco Ave, St. Augustine, FL 32084
- Perfect Gift: Fresh coffee beans or a boho-chic throw blanket.
- Who Will Love It: The design-savvy decorator, artisan lover, or anyone who just loves a plain ol’ cup of joe.
🎁 For the Party Starter: Happy Pappy’s Glow Balls
This fun-filled store specializes in glowing, light-up gifts and neon-themed accessories. It’s a one-stop shop for adding sparkle to any celebration.
- Address: 76 San Marco Ave, St. Augustine, FL 32084
- Perfect Gift: A set of glow-in-the-dark handing lamps in the shape of their favorite emoji!
- Who Will Love It: Kids, party enthusiasts, and anyone who loves a little sparkle in their life.
🎁 For the Coastal Fashionista: Gigi Rae
Gigi Rae is the epitome of laid-back elegance, offering beach-inspired apparel, jewelry, and accessories with a boho flair.
- Address: 10620 US-1 Ste 305, Ponte Vedra Beach, FL 32081
- Perfect Gift: A breezy sundress or a delicate coastal-inspired necklace.
- Who Will Love It: The beach babe, stylish traveler, or anyone who dreams of endless summers.
🎁 For the Fun & Funky Friend: Duddingtons
Duddington brings all the fun and uniqueness to STA. Whether you need a tote bag or sunglasses, they’ve got it all.
- Address: 77 San Marco Ave Suite #1, St. Augustine, FL 32084
- Perfect Gift: Jewelry, clothes, or a fab art piece!
- Who Will Love It: The thrifter, traveler, or anyone who appreciates the beautiful things in life.
🎁 For the Dessert Devotee: Creme de la Cocoa
This gourmet dessert shop crafts mouthwatering chocolates, artistic cakes, and pastries that are as beautiful as they are delicious.
- Address: 299 San Marco Ave, St. Augustine, FL 32084
- Perfect Gift: A box of artisanal chocolates or a gift card for their custom cakes.
- Who Will Love It: The sweet tooth, foodie, or host with the most.
🎁 For the Globetrotting Adventurer: Crafts Without Borders
Celebrate global artistry with this unique shop that brings handmade goods from around the world to St. Augustine. Think woven baskets, intricate textiles, and artisan crafts.
- Address: 74 San Marco Ave, St. Augustine, FL 32084
- Perfect Gift: A handwoven basket or a fair-trade scarf.
- Who Will Love It: The cultural explorer, ethical shopper, or anyone who values meaningful gifts.
🎁 For the Sweet Tooth: Cookiebird Ice Cream
A whimsical ice cream shop specializing in soft serve, milk buns, and shakes.
- Address: 138 San Marco Ave, St. Augustine, FL 32084
- Perfect Gift: Branded merch or an exclusive gift card.
- Who Will Love It: The dessert conessioure or sweet-toothed someone in your life.
🎁 For the Coastal Enthusiast: Coastal Traders
Bring Indonesia to your home. Coastal Traders features home goods, local art, and overall funky items.
- Address: 56 San Marco Ave, St. Augustine, FL 32084
- Perfect Gift: A shell wind chime or a pearl pendant necklace.
- Who Will Love It: The traveler, the “no one else will have this!” friend, and anyone decorating their dream house.
🎁 For the Treasure Hunter: 312 Pawn Shop
This local pawn shop is a treasure chest of vintage finds, rare collectibles, and even surfboards. You never know what you’ll discover.
- Address: 1955 A1A S, St. Augustine, FL 32080
- Perfect Gift: A vintage record player or unique collectible.
- Who Will Love It: The thrifty treasure hunter, surfer, or anyone who loves vintage vibes.
🎁 For the Tea Drinker: The Spice & Tea Exchange of St. Augustine
Tea as far as the eye can see. Taste test tea and spices from all over the world.
- Address: 59 Hypolita St #3656, St. Augustine, FL 32084
- Perfect Gift: Loose-leaf tea set or bourbon sampler.
- Who Will Love It: The “I don’t like coffee” person, the foodie, the gourmet lover.
🎁 For Him: Mustache
Woodworking, leather, hand-crafted tools, ceramic goods – find it all here.
- Address: 70 St George St, St. Augustine, FL 32084
- Perfect Gift: Scented beard balm, whiskey smoker, brass lighter.
- Who Will Love It: The man’s man, the camper, the woodworker, and Ron Swanson.
To Wrap It Up
Shopping in St. Augustine means more than just buying gifts—it’s about discovering pieces of the city’s charm to share with your loved ones. From glowing toys to decadent chocolates, there’s something for everyone on your list.
What’s your favorite shop from this list? Share your finds and tag us on Instagram (@YourKeytoStAugustine)! 🎁