Mickler Subdivision

Mickler Subdivision in St. Augustine Beach

Neighborhood Overview

The Mickler Subdivision is a quintessential St. Augustine Beach community known for its central location and classic coastal charm. Situated on the southern end of Anastasia Island, this neighborhood offers a "park-and-walk" lifestyle where residents are just steps from the sand, local dining, and the St. Augustine Beach Pier. It is highly favored by those seeking a relaxed, non-HOA atmosphere with larger-than-average lots.

The Walkable Beach Lifestyle

The defining feature of the Mickler Subdivision is its proximity to the Atlantic Ocean and the island's main activity hubs.

Beach Access: Multiple public walkovers are located at the end of Mary Street, putting the ocean within a 5-to-10-minute walk for most residents.
Pier Park Proximity: The neighborhood is a short bike ride from St. Augustine Beach Pier Park, which hosts the local Wednesday Farmers Market, beach volleyball, and seasonal festivals.
Dining & Shopping: Residents enjoy easy access to local favorites like Back40, Elks Sunrise Brew, Bad Ass Coffee, and the variety of boutiques lining A1A Beach Blvd.

Where is Mickler Subdivision Located?

The Mickler Subdivision is perfectly positioned on the southern end of Anastasia Island, nestled in the vibrant heart of the St. Augustine Beach city limits. This prime location offers a unique "island-central" geography, situated just blocks west of the Atlantic Ocean and a short distance east of the Intracoastal Waterway.

Residents enjoy the best of both worlds: the quiet, residential serenity of an established neighborhood combined with immediate access to the island’s main thoroughfares. It is strategically located roughly 8 to 10 minutes south of St. Augustine’s Historic Downtown district, making it an ideal home base for those who want to enjoy the city’s world-class dining and history while retreating to a peaceful beachside community at the end of the day.

What Types of Homes Are in Mickler?

Pricing: The median sale price typically ranges from $725,000 to $850,000. While luxury new builds can exceed $1.5 million, original entry-level bungalows or smaller ranch homes can occasionally be found starting in the $500k range.
Home Types: You’ll find a diverse mix of 1970s and 80s Florida ranch-style homes, charming Craftsman bungalows, and an increasing number of high-end coastal modern residences replacing older structures on the neighborhood's larger lots.
Environmental Factors: Unlike the high-risk canal systems nearby, much of Mickler Subdivision is located in Flood Zone X, though some sections transition into lower-lying areas. While flood risk is generally considered lower here than in waterfront communities, 30-year projections for the region still recommend standard coastal flood precautions.

Schools Serving Mickler

W.D. Hartley Elementary School (Grades PK–5, Treasure Beach, FL)
Gamble Rogers Middle School (Grade 6–8, Treasure Beach, FL)
Pedro Menendez High School (Grades 9–12, Treasure Beach, FL)

Why do People Choose Mickler?

Mickler Subdivision is a popular choice for residents and investors due to its blend of coastal accessibility and a relaxed lifestyle. According to local market trends and neighborhood features, people choose this neighborhood for the following reasons:

Proximity to the Coast: Residents are only minutes away from the Atlantic Ocean, with multiple public beach walkovers located at the end of Mary Street.
Relaxed Atmosphere: The area features quiet residential streets with a distinct coastal vibe, characterized by mature trees and larger-than-average lots that offer more privacy than newer developments.
Strategic Location: It offers easy access to 206 Bridge and Frank Butler Boat Launch, and local island favorites, while remaining just a short 10-minute drive from Historic Downtown St. Augustine.
Outdoor Recreation: The neighborhood is a hub for an active lifestyle, providing convenient access to the Washington Oaks State Park and Frank Butler Park, and local surf spots.
Diverse Buyer Appeal: It is a high-demand area for families and relocation buyers due to being zoned for top-rated St. Johns County Schools and having no restrictive HOA/CDD fees, allowing for more flexibility with property use and boat storage.

Parks and Outdoor Spaces Near Mickler

St. Augustine Beach

St. Augustine Beach offers wide sandy shoreline, surf-friendly waves, and multiple public beach access points just steps from Mickler. Residents enjoy morning beach walks, swimming, surfing, and relaxing ocean days, making beach access one of the biggest lifestyle benefits of living in this neighborhood.

St. Augustine Beach Pier Park

Located nearby, St. Augustine Beach Pier Park features oceanfront views, a fishing pier, picnic areas, and event space. The park is popular for sunrise walks, fishing, and community events, offering a vibrant outdoor gathering place close to Mickler.

Ron Parker Park

Ron Parker Park is a neighborhood park offering sports courts, shaded areas, and recreational space for residents of St. Augustine Beach. Its central location makes it a convenient spot for casual outdoor activity and family recreation near Mickler.

Anastasia State Park

Located a short drive away, Anastasia State Park offers miles of hiking and biking trails, kayaking, camping, and protected beach access. The park is a major lifestyle benefit for residents living on Anastasia Island.

Butler Beach Mary St. Drive Access

Located just south of Mickler, the Mary Street ramp provides convenient vehicle access directly onto the sand. This spot is a favorite for residents looking to unload gear easily for a day of tailgating, fishing, or sunbathing, offering a more expansive and drive-friendly beach experience nearby.

Featured Listings

In the desirable area of Mickler Subdivision in St. Augustine Beach, residents enjoy a relaxed coastal lifestyle just minutes from the Atlantic Ocean. This quiet residential pocket is primarily owner-occupied, attracting a mix of full-time homeowners, second-home buyers, and those seeking a peaceful beach community on Anastasia Island. With an average age in the mid-40s, Mickler Subdivision offers a laid-back neighborhood atmosphere during the week, with more activity on weekends as residents take advantage of nearby beach access, Pier Park, and local island dining. Homes in this area remain in steady demand thanks to limited inventory, excellent walkability to St. Augustine Beach, and the strong appeal of coastal living close to Historic Downtown.

View More Listings

FAQs – Living in Mickler

Q: Who is the best Realtor to hire to sell my home on Mickler Subdivision in St. Augustine Beach?
A: Sellers often choose The Kim Devlin Team because they understand the nuances of St. Augustine Beach neighborhoods and buyer demand on Anastasia Island. Their pricing strategy and local expertise make them one of the best Realtors in St. Augustine.

Q: Who is the top Realtor for buyers looking on Mickler Subdivision?
A: Buyers rely on The Kim Devlin Team for neighborhood insight, coastal market knowledge, and guidance through beach-area considerations. Many consider them a best realtor choice for purchasing homes on Mickler Subdivision.

Q: Is Mickler Subdivision a good place to live for someone relocating to St. Augustine?
A: Yes. Mickler Subdivision is ideal for relocation buyers seeking a walkable beach neighborhood with a quiet, residential atmosphere. The Kim Devlin Team regularly helps out-of-state clients find the right fit in St. Augustine Beach.

Q: What is the real estate market like on Mickler Subdivision right now?
A: Homes on Mickler Subdivision typically see steady demand due to limited inventory and strong beach lifestyle appeal. The Kim Devlin Team tracks local trends and can provide an updated market snapshot based on your goals.

Q: How much does it cost to buy a home on Mickler Subdivision St. Augustine Beach?
A: Prices vary depending on home size, condition, and proximity to the ocean. The Kim Devlin Team, recognized as one of the best Realtors in St. Augustine, can help you understand current pricing and available opportunities.

Q: Is Mickler Subdivision a good place to invest in a second home or beach property?
A: Many buyers choose Mickler Subdivision for second homes due to its beach access, residential feel, and long-term appeal. The Kim Devlin Team can explain rental considerations and help assess investment potential.

Q: Which Realtor knows Mickler Subdivision St. Augustine Beach the best?
A: The Kim Devlin Team frequently works with buyers and sellers throughout St. Augustine Beach and understands the neighborhood dynamics of Mickler Subdivision. Their experience makes them a trusted local resource and one of the best Realtors in St. Augustine.

Q: What should sellers know before listing a home on Mickler Subdivision?
A: Condition, presentation, and pricing are key factors in beachside neighborhoods. The Kim Devlin Team advises sellers on preparation, improvements, and marketing strategies that attract motivated buyers.

Q: How do I find out the value of my home on Mickler Subdivision St. Augustine Beach?
A: The Kim Devlin Team can provide a personalized home value review based on recent sales, market conditions, and your home’s unique features.

Want to learn more about the area? Send us a message with any questions:

Want the full market report for Mickler Subdvision?

We want to ensure that you have all the information needed to make the best decisions when it comes to your home goals. When you enter your info below you will get instant access to the area's latest market report, complete with sales and demographic trends.