Whether you’re planning a visit or considering moving to St. Augustine Florida, one of the first questions you’ll ask is: “What part of St. Augustine should I stay in?”
That’s a fair question — because St. Augustine isn’t a one-size-fits-all city. It’s a patchwork of historic charm, coastal beauty, suburban comfort, and growing master-planned communities. Each neighborhood has its own rhythm, price point, and personality.
As a local Realtor in St. Augustine, I’ve helped hundreds of families, retirees, and newcomers explore the best neighborhoods to live in St. Augustine Florida — and today, I’m breaking down what makes each area unique so you can find your perfect fit.
1. Historic Downtown – For Culture Lovers and Walkability
If you dream of cobblestone streets, art galleries, and coffee shops within walking distance, Historic Downtown St. Augustine is your match.
-
Lifestyle: Walkable, lively, and full of energy.
-
Vibe: Historic and charming, with plenty of live music and local restaurants.
-
Stay Here If: You love architecture, culture, and being at the heart of everything.
Downtown is perfect for those who enjoy living in St. Augustine FL with a mix of old-world charm and modern conveniences. But remember — parking can be tricky, and weekends are bustling with tourists.
2. Anastasia Island & St. Augustine Beach – For Beach Lovers
Just across the Bridge of Lions, Anastasia Island and St. Augustine Beach are where locals and visitors go to slow down and soak up the coastal lifestyle.
-
Lifestyle: Morning walks on the beach, surf spots, seafood by the shore.
-
Vibe: Relaxed and laid-back with a true beach-town feel.
-
Stay Here If: You want to wake up to ocean breezes and spend your days outdoors.
You’ll find everything from oceanfront condos to family-friendly neighborhoods. For many, this is one of the top places to live in St. Augustine Florida — combining coastal calm with quick access to downtown.
3. Vilano Beach – For Waterfront Views & Peace
Just north of downtown, Vilano Beach offers a quieter alternative to the main beaches — and stunning views of the Intracoastal and the Atlantic.
-
Lifestyle: Coastal luxury meets small-town charm.
-
Vibe: Peaceful, private, and upscale.
-
Stay Here If: You want a serene beach experience away from crowds.
Vilano’s blend of modern homes and waterfront estates makes it one of the best neighborhoods to live in St. Augustine Florida for those seeking beauty and tranquility.
4. World Golf Village – For Families & Suburban Comfort
If you’re searching for master-planned living, World Golf Village in St. Johns County Florida is a standout.
-
Lifestyle: Golf, family amenities, and community events.
-
Vibe: Safe, friendly, and family-focused.
-
Stay Here If: You prefer newer construction, great schools, and a quiet suburban feel.
Located west of I-95, it’s a 25–30 minute drive to the beach or downtown — but the space, schools, and amenities make it worth it for families moving to St. Augustine FL.
5. Nocatee & Ponte Vedra – For Resort-Style Living
Technically just north of St. Augustine, Nocatee and Ponte Vedra sit on the border of St. Johns County Florida, offering luxury living with big amenities.
-
Lifestyle: Resort pools, golf, walking trails, and A-rated schools.
-
Vibe: Upscale, active, and ideal for families or retirees who want convenience.
-
Stay Here If: You want a blend of coastal access and suburban comfort.
Ponte Vedra is also known for its golf culture and proximity to Jacksonville, making it a strong choice for commuters or remote workers who want a balance of luxury and leisure.
6. Palencia – For Balance and Convenience
Located between downtown St. Augustine and Nocatee, Palencia is a beautiful master-planned community that blends family comfort with upscale amenities.
-
Lifestyle: Golf, fitness, dining, and quick access to both downtown and the beach.
-
Vibe: Polished and peaceful.
-
Stay Here If: You want a convenient, community-focused neighborhood with plenty of green space.
Palencia remains one of the top places to live in St. Augustine Florida for those seeking a high-quality lifestyle in a prime location.
7. Palm Coast – For Affordability & Space
About 30 minutes south of St. Augustine, Palm Coast offers affordability, newer homes, and a slower pace — perfect for those who want coastal living without the premium price.
-
Lifestyle: Golf, boating, biking, and nature preserves.
-
Vibe: Relaxed, friendly, and family-oriented.
-
Stay Here If: You want more space for your money while staying close to St. Augustine and Daytona Beach.
Palm Coast is growing fast and is often compared favorably to St. Augustine for its cost of living — making it a great option for families moving to St. Augustine Florida who want more room to grow.
Choosing the Right Area for You
So — which part of St. Augustine FL should you stay in?
It depends on your priorities:
| Lifestyle Goal | Best Area |
|---|---|
| Walkability & Culture | Historic Downtown |
| Beach Access | Anastasia Island or St. Augustine Beach |
| Waterfront Living | Vilano Beach |
| Family Amenities | World Golf Village |
| Luxury & Schools | Nocatee / Ponte Vedra |
| Balance & Community | Palencia |
| Affordability | Palm Coast |
If you’re unsure, start by visiting a few neighborhoods — or better yet, talk with a local expert who can help you compare where to live in St. Augustine Florida based on your goals and budget.
Conclusion
Whether you’re here for a season or ready to call it home, St. Augustine Florida has a neighborhood that fits every lifestyle. From historic downtown streets to beachside communities and suburban retreats, there’s a perfect corner of this city waiting for you.
👉 Thinking about moving to St. Augustine FL? Contact Kim Devlin, your trusted Realtor in St. Augustine, her team specializes in helping newcomers explore the best neighborhoods to live in St. Augustine Florida and St. Johns County Florida — from Palm Coast to Nocatee.
Let’s find your ideal place to stay, live, and thrive in St. Augustine FL!