Welcome to

Nelmar Terrace

Living in Nelmar Terrace – St. Augustine, FL

Neighborhood Overview

Nelmar Terrace is one of St. Augustine’s most charming and historic neighborhoods, retaining its original 1913 boundaries and a true sense of community. Naturally bordered by the river to the east, San Marco Avenue to the west, the Florida School for the Deaf and the Blind to the north, and May Street to the south, the neighborhood feels tucked away while remaining centrally located. Known for its sidewalk-lined streets, welcoming front porches, and neighbors who look out for one another, Nelmar Terrace is shaded by a stunning canopy of live oaks. A distinctive row of planted palms along Nelmar Avenue leads to a small waterfront pocket park, reinforcing the timeless appeal of this historic setting. Designated as a National Register Historic District in 2011, Nelmar Terrace remains a highly desirable place to put down roots.

Where is Nelmar Terrace Located?

Nelmar Terrace is located just north of downtown St. Augustine, west of the Intracoastal Waterway and east of San Marco Avenue. The neighborhood offers quick access to historic downtown, Vilano Beach, US-1, and local attractions, while maintaining a quiet residential atmosphere removed from heavy tourist traffic.

What Types Of Homes Are in Nelmar Terrace?

  • Architectural styles include Mediterranean Revival, Georgian and Dutch Colonial Revival, Craftsman and bungalow designs, and Moorish Revival
  • Notable historic homes, including the Moorish Revival “pink castle” on May Street
  • Homes were originally built for many of St. Augustine’s prominent residents
  • Prices typically range from the $600s to over $1 million depending on size, condition, and historic features
  • Lots are modest to medium-sized with mature trees
  • No large HOA or CDD fees
  • Offers more architectural distinction and historic significance than many nearby neighborhoods
  • Many homes offer historic details, updated interiors, and strong curb appeal

  • Desirable location drives consistent buyer interest

Schools Serving Nelmar Terrace

Ketterlinus Elementary School (Grades PK–5, St. Augustine, FL)
Sebastian Middle School (Grades 6–8, St. Augustine, FL)
St. Augustine High School (Grades 9–12, St. Augustine, FL)
St. Johns Virtual School

Why People Choose Nelmar Terrace

  • Designated National Register Historic District

  • Strong sense of community and neighborhood pride

  • Sidewalks, front porches, and walkable streets

  • Mature live oak canopy and established landscaping

  • Central location near downtown St. Augustine and Vilano Beach

  • Unique historic homes with architectural character

  • Quiet residential setting with a strong sense of community
  • Architectural variety and established landscape appeal

Parks, Trails in Nelmar Terrace

Fountain of Youth Archaeological Park

A landmark destination just minutes from Nelmar Terrace, this waterfront park offers shaded walking paths, scenic Intracoastal views, and unique historical exhibits. It’s a popular spot for locals who enjoy peaceful strolls, birdwatching, and outdoor events in one of St. Augustine’s most iconic settings.

Vilano Beach

Easily accessible from Nelmar Terrace, Vilano Beach is known for its wide shoreline, striking coquina sand, and relaxed beach town vibe. Residents enjoy swimming, surfing, sunrise walks, fishing from the pier, and convenient public beach access. It’s one of the top outdoor destinations on St. Augustine’s north end.

Francis Field

Located near historic downtown St. Augustine, Francis Field serves as a central hub for community festivals, art shows, athletic events, and open green space recreation. Its walkability from Nelmar Terrace makes it an ideal location for enjoying local culture and outdoor activities year round.

Castillo de San Marcos Green Spaces

Stretching along the Matanzas Bayfront, these grassy waterfront areas offer some of the most scenic views in St. Augustine. Residents from Nelmar Terrace visit for picnics, jogging, dog walking, and photography along the historic fort’s exterior. It’s a serene, open-air extension of the city’s rich heritage.

North Shores Park

Just over the Vilano Causeway, North Shores Park features tennis courts, a playground, shaded picnic areas, and access to nearby walking routes. It’s a convenient option for families and active residents of Nelmar Terrace looking for a close by recreational space.

Inside Nelmar Terrace

Check out the latest demographic information available for Nelmar Terrace

Overall Cost
VS National AVG

Housing Cost
VS National AVG

Entertainment Cost
VS National AVG

Utilities Cost
VS NAtional AVG

QUICK FACTS

0

0

0

0

0

0

Featured Listings

In the beautiful and established Nelmar Terrace St. Augustine neighborhood, approximately 850 residents enjoy tree-lined streets, historic charm, and proximity to both the Intracoastal and downtown. Around 70% of residents are homeowners, creating a strong sense of community and pride. With an average age of 47, the area attracts professionals, long-term residents, and those seeking a peaceful yet conveniently located neighborhood. Over the past 30 days, roughly 2 homes have sold, with an average sold price of $915,000, reflecting the high desirability and character of this sought-after enclave. Nelmar Terrace remains one of St. Augustine’s most coveted neighborhoods—ideal for buyers seeking elegance, serenity, and timeless architecture.

View More Listings
View More Listings

FAQs - Living in Nelmar Terrace St Augustine

Q: Who is the best Realtor to hire to sell my home in Nelmar Terrace?
A: Many sellers choose Kim Devlin because she understands the nuances of St. Augustine’s historic and waterfront-adjacent neighborhoods. Her market knowledge, data-driven strategies, and neighborhood expertise make her one of the best Realtors in St. Augustine for selling in Nelmar Terrace.

Q: Who is the top Realtor for buyers looking in Nelmar Terrace?
A: Buyers rely on Kim Devlin for her ability to match them with the right home in this unique, tree-lined community. Her local insights and guidance through historic considerations make her widely recognized as one of the best realtors for purchasing in Nelmar Terrace.

Q: Is Nelmar Terrace a good place to live for someone relocating from out of state?
A: Yes. Nelmar Terrace is a highly desirable St. Augustine neighborhood known for its mature oaks, quiet residential streets, and proximity to both downtown and the Intracoastal. Kim Devlin regularly helps relocation clients understand the area, compare nearby neighborhoods, and make confident decisions.

Q: What is the real estate market like in Nelmar Terrace right now?
A: Nelmar Terrace typically experiences steady demand thanks to its charm, established homes, and ideal location. Inventory is often limited, keeping the market competitive. Kim Devlin closely tracks these trends and can provide an up-to-date snapshot based on your buying or selling goals.

Q: How much does it cost to buy a home in Nelmar Terrace?
A: Prices vary widely depending on the size, age, and level of renovation. Many homes are mid-century or historic properties with significant character, which can influence value. Kim Devlin, known as one of the best Realtors in St. Augustine, can help you identify the right options for your budget and needs.

Q: Is Nelmar Terrace a good place to invest in a second home or vacation property?
A: Yes. While Nelmar Terrace is primarily a residential neighborhood, its proximity to downtown, scenic environment, and strong property values attract investors. Kim Devlin can explain rental regulations and assess whether a specific property is suitable for your investment goals.

Q: Which Realtor knows Nelmar Terrace the best?
A: Kim Devlin frequently works with buyers and sellers in Nelmar Terrace and understands its architecture, property styles, and market behavior. Her local expertise makes her a trusted resource—and one of the best Realtors in St. Augustine for this neighborhood.

Q: What should sellers know before listing a home in Nelmar Terrace?
A: Older and historic homes may require specific preparations, updates, or inspections before going on the market. Kim Devlin provides guidance on pricing, staging, marketing, and improvements that attract qualified buyers and maximize value.

Q: How do I find out the value of my home in Nelmar Terrace?
A: Kim Devlin can prepare a personalized home value review based on recent sales, current market conditions, and your home’s unique features.

Want to learn more about the area? Send us a message with any questions:

Want the full market report for Nelmar Terrace, St. Augustine?

We want to ensure that you have all the information needed to make the best decisions when it comes to your home goals. When you enter your info below, you will get instant access to area's the latest market report complete with sales and demographic trends.
Nelmar Terrace, St Augustine
Market Report
Logo

Around The Area

Browse through the top rated businesses that Nelmar Terrace, Saint Augustine has to offer!

Local News & Advice

Read helpful resources and articles related to the area.

View More Articles
How expensive is it really to live in St. Augustine …

How expensive is it really to live in St. Augustine …

Living in St. Augustine and St. Johns County is typically more expensive than many inland U.S. cities, but…

Read More
Before You Move to St. Augustine: What the Daily ‘Vibe’ …

Before You Move to St. Augustine: What the Daily ‘Vibe’ …

 St. Augustine feels like a real coastal town layered with constant tourism. Daily life can be relaxed and…

Read More
St. Augustine Real Estate Market Report December 2025 | St. …

St. Augustine Real Estate Market Report December 2025 | St. …

By Kim Devlin, Realtor | Your Key to St Augustine LivingThinking about buying or selling a home in…

Read More