Best Neighborhoods in St. Johns County, Florida: Finding Your Perfect Place to Call Home


St. Johns County, Florida, is known for its beautiful coastal scenery, vibrant communities, and excellent quality of life. If you’re considering a move to this desirable area, it’s essential to find the right neighborhood that suits your lifestyle and preferences. With countless options available, navigating the St. Johns County real estate market can be overwhelming. Fortunately, has done the research for you. By analyzing key factors such as school quality, safety, cost of living, real estate market, and community amenities, they have identified the top 5 neighborhoods in St. Johns County. Let’s dive into the details and discover what makes these neighborhoods stand out from the rest. employed a comprehensive methodology to determine the top neighborhoods in St. Johns County, taking into account various essential factors. Their evaluation included school ratings, crime rates, cost of living, housing trends, and amenities. By combining these elements, compiled a reliable ranking that can help you make an informed decision when choosing your future neighborhood.

Ponte Vedra Beach/ Palm Valley/ Sawgrass

Ponte Vedra Beach is a highly sought-after neighborhood in St. Johns County. Renowned for its picturesque beaches, world-class golf courses, and upscale amenities, Ponte Vedra Beach offers a luxurious and vibrant coastal lifestyle. The neighborhood boasts excellent schools, including top-rated public and private institutions that prioritize education and academic excellence. Safety is a priority in Ponte Vedra Beach, with low crime rates and a strong sense of community vigilance.

While the cost of living in Ponte Vedra Beach may be higher than in other areas of St. Johns County, residents enjoy a high standard of living and a wide range of housing options. From stunning oceanfront properties to gated communities with luxurious homes, Ponte Vedra Beach offers something for everyone. The real estate market in this neighborhood is thriving, with a strong demand for properties and stable property values.

Community amenities are abundant in Ponte Vedra Beach. Residents have access to exclusive beach clubs, world-class golf courses, tennis facilities, and upscale shopping and dining options. The community takes pride in its well-maintained parks, nature preserves, and recreational areas, providing ample opportunities for outdoor activities and relaxation.


Nocatee is a master-planned community that has gained significant popularity in recent years. This neighborhood offers a well-balanced lifestyle, combining natural beauty with modern conveniences. Nocatee excels in providing top-notch educational opportunities for its residents, with highly rated schools within the community. Families can feel secure in the neighborhood’s commitment to safety, as it consistently maintains low crime rates.

One of the attractive aspects of Nocatee is its affordability. The cost of living in this neighborhood is relatively reasonable compared to some other areas in St. Johns County. The real estate market in Nocatee is thriving, offering a range of housing options suitable for various budgets and preferences. From spacious single-family homes to stylish townhouses, Nocatee has diverse options for homebuyers.

Nocatee takes pride in its abundance of community amenities. The neighborhood boasts impressive recreational facilities, including swimming pools, fitness centers, parks, and miles of walking and biking trails. Residents can enjoy a resort-like atmosphere with access to a private water park, splash pads, and a variety of community events and social activities.

Living in St Augustine, St Augustine Realtor, St Augustine Real Estate, St Augustine FL, St Augustine Beach, Anastasia Island, Best Realtor St Augustine, Palm Coast, Ponte Vedra, St Johns County Florida, florida housing market update, dog friendly st augustine

Julington Creek/Fruit Cove

Julington Creek is a family-friendly neighborhood known for its excellent schools, safe environment, and strong sense of community. The neighborhood offers top-rated public and private schools that prioritize academic excellence and provide a nurturing learning environment for children. Safety is a paramount concern in Julington Creek, with low crime rates and active community involvement in neighborhood watch programs.

In terms of cost of living, Julington Creek provides a balance between affordability and quality. The neighborhood offers a range of housing options, from single-family homes to townhouses and apartments, accommodating various budgets and lifestyles. The real estate market in Julington Creek is stable, with a steady demand for properties and consistent property values.

Julington Creek offers an array of community amenities designed to enhance residents’ quality of life. The neighborhood features well-maintained parks, playgrounds, and sports fields where families can enjoy outdoor activities. Additionally, there are community pools, fitness centers, and recreational facilities that cater to residents’ active lifestyles. The neighborhood’s close proximity to the St. Johns River also provides opportunities for boating, fishing, and other water-based activities.

St. Augustine/ World Golf Village

St. Augustine, the oldest city in the United States, offers a unique blend of rich history, cultural charm, and modern living. The neighborhood boasts a diverse range of schools, including public, private, and charter institutions, ensuring quality education for residents. Safety is a top priority in St. Augustine, with a dedicated police force and proactive community involvement in maintaining a secure environment.

While the cost of living in St. Augustine may be slightly higher than some other neighborhoods in St. Johns County, the investment is well worth it for those seeking a blend of history and modern amenities. The real estate market in St. Augustine offers a mix of historic homes, charming downtown residences, and newer developments to cater to various preferences. The neighborhood’s real estate values have remained stable, making it an attractive option for homebuyers.

St. Augustine is a community rich in culture and amenities. Residents can explore the city’s historic sites, museums, and art galleries, immersing themselves in the area’s fascinating history. The neighborhood also offers a vibrant culinary scene, with a wide range of restaurants and cafes serving diverse cuisines. Outdoor enthusiasts can enjoy recreational activities such as boating, fishing, golfing and exploring the beautiful beaches nearby.

St. Johns

St. Johns is a suburban neighborhood that appeals to families and individuals seeking a peaceful and close-knit community. The neighborhood boasts excellent schools, both public and private, with a focus on academic achievement and holistic development. St. Johns maintains a strong emphasis on safety, with low crime rates and proactive community initiatives to ensure the well-being of its residents.

In terms of the cost of living, St. Johns offers a balance between affordability and quality. The neighborhood provides a variety of housing options, including single-family homes, townhouses, and apartments, accommodating different budgets and lifestyles. The real estate market in St. Johns is thriving, with a range of new developments and established communities, attracting homebuyers looking for a suburban oasis.

St. Johns prides itself on its community amenities, with well-maintained parks, sports fields, and playgrounds that cater to residents of all ages. The neighborhood offers an abundance of outdoor recreational activities, including hiking and biking trails, golf courses, and community events that foster a sense of belonging and camaraderie among residents.


Choosing the right neighborhood is crucial when considering a move to St. Johns County, FL.’s comprehensive evaluation has identified the top 5 neighborhoods: Ponte Vedra Beach, Nocatee, Julington Creek, St. Augustine, and St. Johns. Each neighborhood offers unique characteristics, from coastal luxury to family-friendly suburbs and historic charm. By considering factors such as school quality, safety, cost of living, real estate market, and community amenities, prospective residents can make an informed decision and find their perfect place to call home in St. Johns County. Whether you prioritize excellent schools, a strong sense of community, or access to recreational amenities, there is a neighborhood in St. Johns County that will meet your needs and provide an exceptional quality of life.

About the Author
Kim Devlin
Kim Devlin is Your St Augustine Realtor. A Relocation Specialist serving Northeast Florida, St Johns County and Flagler County. She enjoys sharing real estate tips and local insight on communities and living in St Augustine Florida. Tune in weekly and be sure to subscribe to her monthly newsletter.